Problem 12 Assume firms in the short run ar... [FREE SOLUTION] (2024)

Expert verified

In the realm of market structures, a pure monopoly is a unique scenario where a single firm has complete control over the supply of a product or service, with no close substitutes available to consumers. This exclusive position often results from strong barriers to entry, such as patents, high start-up costs, or exclusive access to a resource, which prevent other companies from competing in the market.

What makes a pure monopoly particularly interesting in economic studies is its ability to maintain above-normal profits in the long run. Since it's virtually impossible for new competitors to enter the market, the monopolist can set prices above the marginal cost without fear of losing market share. This dynamic allows the firm to enjoy a larger profit margin, ensuring those above-normal profits persist over time.

To fully grasp the concept, imagine a patented drug that can only be produced by one pharmaceutical company. Due to this exclusivity and the absence of substitutes, the company can sustain high profits indefinitely, unless the patent expires or new legislation changes the market conditions.

Oligopoly presents a market structure where a small number of large firms hold the majority of market share. These firms are typically powerful and conscious of each other's actions, making the market highly competitive, yet not in the traditional sense.

Barriers to entry in an oligopoly might include significant economies of scale or strategic actions by incumbents to deter newcomers. While firms in an oligopoly may earn above-normal profits in the short term, these are not guaranteed in the long run. Potential erosion of these profits could be attributed to strategic interactions among firms, such as price wars or increased non-price competition, and the potential for new entrants if the barriers to entry can be overcome. However, it is also possible for firms to tacitly or explicitly collude to maintain high prices and, therefore, above-normal profits.

An excellent example of oligopoly firms is the major airline companies that dominate air travel. They may reap above-normal profits through various strategies, such as loyalty programs, unique services, or controlling key routes, but must be wary of new budget airlines that could disrupt their balance.

Differing from a monopoly, monopolistic competition describes a market where many firms compete by selling products that are differentiated from one another in some way. This differentiation could be based on branding, quality, location, or other attributes, making each firm's product distinct.

In the short run, firms can achieve above-normal profits due to differentiation. However, these profits are not sustainable in the long run. Over time, the success of one firm often attracts new entrants, which increases competition and leads to a decline in the market share of existing firms. As new entrants continue to introduce similar products, the market becomes more saturated, causing the original firm's demand curve to become more elastic. Ultimately, this process drives profits down to a normal level where firms earn just enough to stay in business.

An example often used to illustrate monopolistic competition is the restaurant industry. Many restaurants may offer unique dining experiences or cuisine, initially drawing a higher profit. Still, their success could inspire other restaurateurs to open similar establishments, which dilutes the market and reduces profitability over time.

The epitome of a competitive market, perfect competition, describes a scenario where numerous firms sell identical products, making price the sole factor differentiating sellers in the eyes of consumers. Since no firm is large enough to influence market prices, they are price takers, and the market dictates the equilibrium price based on overall supply and demand.

In such a competitive environment, the occurrence of above-normal profits is a short-lived phenomenon. If firms earn more than the normal profit level, it sends a signal to potential entrants that there is money to be made in that market. As new firms enter, the increase in product supply leads to a decrease in the market price. This cycle continues until the profits are eroded to the point where firms are only making normal profits. It's a self-regulating mechanism ensuring that no firm can earn more than its competitors for an extended period.

A commonly cited example of perfect competition is agriculture, where numerous farmers offer similar products. If one farmer manages to cut costs and earn higher profits, others will follow suit, adopt the cost-saving techniques, and restore the balance in profitability.

Understanding long-run market dynamics is crucial for comprehending how profits and competition evolve over time. In economics, the long run refers to a period in which all factors of production can be varied, allowing firms to adjust their production levels and new firms to enter or exit the market. This contrasts with the short run, where certain factors are fixed and unchangeable.

In the long run, market dynamics tend to push profits toward a normal level due to the freedom of entry and exit. Above-normal profits invite competition, while below-normal profits encourage firms to leave the market. Over time, this leads to an equilibrium where only normal profits, which provide firms with just enough incentive to stay in the market, are achieved.

For instance, technological innovation in an industry may initially grant certain firms above-normal profits. However, as this technology becomes widely adopted and more firms enter the market to capitalize on these profits, the overall competition will increase, inevitably leading to normal profit levels.

Barriers to entry are obstacles that make it difficult or costly for new firms to enter an industry, hence protecting the profits of existing firms. These barriers can be natural or artificial, stemming from various factors including economies of scale, legal restrictions, strong brand identities, control of essential resources, or high capital requirements.

Firms behind high barriers to entry can deter new competitors, thereby maintaining their market position and the ability to set prices above marginal cost. As a consequence, these firms can sustain above-normal profits since potential rivals are blocked from the market.

For example, utility companies often operate under conditions akin to a natural monopoly due to the prohibitive costs associated with building infrastructure. These significant capital expenses and regulatory requirements create a barrier high enough to prevent new firms from attempting to enter the market.

Above-normal profits, also known as economic profits, occur when a firm's total revenues exceed all its costs, including opportunity costs. These profits are an indicator of a firm's competitive advantage in the market and can serve as a motivation for entrepreneurs to innovate or improve efficiency.

In a healthy, competitive market, above-normal profits are typically short-lived as they attract new competitors and drive investment in the industry. This influx of competition increases supply, lowers prices, and ultimately brings profits back down to a normal level — where they cover all costs, including opportunity costs, but no more.

For example, a tech company that develops a new, highly demanded smartphone may earn above-normal profits initially. However, as competitors copy the technology or innovate further, the market adjusts, and the above-normal profits will fade, leaving only room for normal profits in the long run.